Even other OnlyFans creators themselves consider this an act of betrayal. , an X-rated creator, stated, “I think subscribing to an OnlyFans account is considered cheating. You are forming a relationship with these creators that, from your end, you think is real.” She emphasized that if you are purchasing explicit videos from a specific person, you are creating a secret dynamic outside your primary relationship. Similarly, creator Maddi Miller broke up with her boyfriend after discovering he was subscribed to accounts of women she personally knew. “It was a huge breach of my trust. I wouldn’t be asking his mates for nudes. It’s the same thing. It’s betrayal,” she told news.com.au, noting the activity occurred while he lay in bed next to her.

For creators like Melany Furie, a viral video title is a finely-tuned marketing funnel designed to convert casual internet searchers into paying subscribers.